SC's Verdict on Racial Gerrymandering Appeal Hits Republicans

Share
SC's Verdict on Racial Gerrymandering Appeal Hits Republicans

A narrowly-divided Supreme Court on Monday dismissed an appeal from Virginia's Republican-controlled House of Delegates which sought to reinstate the state's legislative districts map after it was struck down for improper racial gerrymandering.

The dispute focused on whether the federal Atomic Energy Act of 1954, which regulates the development of nuclear energy, pre-empts Virginia's mining ban under the U.S. Constitution's Supremacy Clause, which holds that federal law generally outweighs state law.

On Monday, in a 5-4 decision, the court said the House of Delegates lacked standing to bring the case. Primarily basically based on a lawsuit, a federal court docket declared the plot invalid, concluding that it unconstitutionally sorted voters basically based mostly on toddle.

Demonstrators protest during a Fair Maps rally outside the U.S. Supreme Court, in Washington, U.S., March 26, 2019.

Justice Samuel Alito dissented, saying he saw no support "for the proposition that Virginia law bars the House from defending, in its own right, the constitutionality of a districting plan". "One house of its bicameral legislature can not alone continue the litigation against the will of its partners in the legislative process", Ginsburg added.

Ginsburg was joined by Justices Thomas, Sotomayor, Kagan, and Gorsuch in ruling that it was not up to the House of Delegates to appeal a case that originally did not even involve them.

"This is a big win for democracy in Virginia". With the decision, court-drawn House maps, which were ordered in 2018, are upheld, and make it harder for Republicans to defend their majority in the House during November elections, according to analysis by the Virginia Public Access Project.

A lower court didn't buy it, so the House of Delegates appealed.

Invalidating the House's redistricting plan "would cause the House to suffer a "concrete" injury", which ought to be considered by the Supreme Court, he wrote.

Sabath: "It certainly closes the chapter on this long-standing federal litigation and from what we have seen, there is no evidence the General Assembly has any interest in revisiting the decision it made early in the 1980's to keep this industry out of Virginia".

"Authority and responsibility for representing the state's interests in civil litigation, Virginia law prescribes, rest exclusively with the state's attorney general", she wrote.

North Carolina attorney Aylett Colston explained in a Twitter thread that because the justices ruled on standing rather than the merits of the case, "it is hard to say" what this decision could mean for others, including one that focuses on her state.

"This is a welcome ruling from the Supreme Court - it's like I've always said, voters should choose their representatives, not the other way around", Northam said on Twitter.

Republicans said both men were hypocritical; Northam and Herring had voted for the original redistricting plans as members of the state Senate.

Virginia's Attorney General Mark Herring, a Democrat, declined to continue pursuing the case, but the Virginia House of Delegates picked up the fight and appealed the decision to the Supreme Court; SCOTUS ruled Monday that a single house of the legislature didn't have authority to do so. The court could deal with it by the end of the term, possibly next week.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Trump launches 2020 reelection campaign, calling U.S. 'envy of the world'
And ahead of the rally, he pushed several of the core issues in his populist, nationalist platform. If anything, the surveys point to another bitterly fought, tight race.

Top Resources for NAHQ CPHQ Exam
This is why it is highly crucial that you go through the exam content outline or exam objectives before you start your study. You don’t need to buy these guides; having one of them is enough to give you all you need to prepare for your test.

The Most Successful X Factor Winners
The song became an instant hit, selling over 1,25 million copies and this in the UK alone, yes , she was the winner of X Factor. M ore recently, “That’s My Goal” reached an outstanding total of 1.12m copies and this just in the UK factor.

Buttigieg: It's 'Almost Certain' America Has Had a Gay President
Coleman broke off their engagement in 1819, after noting in letters to Buchanan unspecified rumors about the future President. Whether or not someone can do the job is more important than their sexual orientation or their age.

Shooting Has Begun on the 'Game of Thrones' Prequel Series
Shooting is happening in Northern Ireland , which is par for the course; that's where Thrones did the bulk of its filming. The plot is said to be set thousands of years before King Robert marched into Winterfell in the first episode.

Firefox 67.0.3 fixes 0-day vulnerability
How to update Firefox browser? ZDnet's Catalin Cimpanu has some insights on the security issue . Alternatively, you can grab the latest version from APKMirror .

Porsche 718 Cayman GT4, Boxster Spyder unveiled
In both the Cayman GT4 and Boxster Spyder , fuel consumption is rated at 10.9 l/100 km, with Carbon dioxide emissions at 249 g/km. Both have a 0 to 100 kmph time of 4.4s, while the Cayman maxes out at 304 kmph, the Spyder get to 301 kmph.

Galaxy Fold ready to hit the market, confirms a Samsung executive
However, the report says, "executives are monitoring the launch and will reduce off shipments if it sells poorly as expected". Huawei Mate X will come with the Android operating system or with another operating system , nothing can be said about it.

How online gaming took over UK slot machines
This has been proven, and with social anxiety also on the rise, it’s easy to see why. However, that is not to say that gaming online is particularly anti-social.

Shikhar Dhawan ruled out of World Cup, Rishabh Pant confirmed as replacement
Dhawan carried on batting and scored a century to earn the man-of-the-match award as India beat the reigning champions by 36 runs. While the X-ray didn't show any fracture, CT scan revealed otherwise and Dhawan was taken to a specialist for further assessment.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.