U.S. Justice Department says Obamacare individual mandate unconstitutional

Share

The Trump administration told a federal court Thursday it won't defend Obamacare against a lawsuit that's trying to strike down most of the law. The first, known as guaranteed issue, requires insurers to offer coverage to everyone regardless of their health background.

They further cast the administration's brief, which was filed in federal court Thursday, as an "attack" on both the rule of law and the stability of the United States' health care system. In the new suit, California is leading a group of Democratically led states in defending the law.

The states argue that because Congress recently repealed a provision that people without health insurance must pay a fine, the requirement to have health insurance is unconstitutional because it is no longer considered a tax.

The chances for that argument succeeding are viewed with deep skepticism by legal experts, in part because Congress itself indicated that the rest of ObamaCare could still stand without the mandate when it moved to repeal the tax penalty a year ago. In the meantime, the existing law will likely remain.

The filing declares unconstitutional the so-called individual mandate-which requires nearly all Americans to purchase health insurance or pay a "tax" if they don't-and calls for several elements of ACA to be invalidated.

Congressional Republicans, who unsuccessfully sought to undo President Barack Obama's signature health care law throughout 2017, added language to the GOP tax bill that ended the controversial tax penalty for those who fail to obtain health care coverage.

Timothy Jost, law professor emeritus at Washington and Lee University in Virginia said the Trump administration is trying to persuade the court to do what it was unable to achieve in Congress a year ago - essentially, repeal key parts of the Obama health law.

"Justice Department attorneys don't withdraw from cases simply because the government is making an argument the lawyers think the courts should or would reject", he said.

Jost said it's telling that three career Justice Department lawyers refused to support the administration's position.

While Justice Department attorneys often advocate for laws they may personally disagree with, those three civil servants instead made a decision to exit from the case, which Bagley described as "almost unheard of".

The mandate introduced with Obamacare, the popular name for the Affordable Care Act (ACA), was meant to ensure a viable health insurance market by forcing younger and healthier Americans to buy coverage.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Woman kidnapped from hospital as newborn in 1998 found alive
After the loss of her pregnancy, she drove to Jacksonville from SC . "I still feel the same way about her", she said at the time. Kamiyah, who has met her biological parents, told HLN a year ago that she loves Williams and still considers her her mother.

Netflix's "Stranger Things" Lands Book Deal Debuting This Fall
The as-yet-untitled gift book will reportedly offer "advice, wisdom, and warnings from the Stranger Things world", says the publisher.

Taliban orders its first ceasefire in 17-year battle
Four people were killed and five wounded by unidentified gunmen in a separate attack on a lawmaker's Nangarhar home on Friday. The Taliban had denounced the gathering, insisting its fight against what it considers are foreign invaders was justified.

Ryan Gosling Is Neil Armstrong In The First Man Trailer
Following the first poster drop earlier today, Universal Pictures has released the first trailer for First Man . Check out the First Man trailer below.

Gay Maryland Candidate Kisses Spouse In Ad Aimed At Trump
Journalist based in Charlotte, North Carolina, whose work has appeared in The Charlotte Observer, Creative Loafing, and more. According to the LGBTQ Victory Fund , his same-sex on-air kiss was the first in a political TV campaign ad.

Yankees Win Battle With ESPN, Won’t Play Sunday Night Before Doubleheader
The issue stems the Yankees being scheduled to take on the Toronto Blue Jays on Sunday Night Baseball on July 8th. The Dodgers-Angels game in Anaheim will replace Yankees-Blue Jays as the Sunday night game on ESPN.

President Trump signs VA Mission Act
Supporters of the change, like Haynes, say for many that will mean less travel to get their care. The care will be judged by its timeliness, effectiveness, safety, and efficiency.

Murray's Wimbledon hopes hit after tournament pull-out
"It is with regret that I won't be ready to play in Hertogenbosch", said Murray last night. Play begins at Wimbledon on July 2.

Jude takes its final turn as U.S. Open tune-up
Does he have what it takes to make a run at TPC Southwind this week? Crucially, he has improved all round in his ball striking. Accuracy is key this week; it's imperative to avoid all that water if you're to have a chance on the back nine come Sunday.

Stephens downs Keys again to reach French Open final
It would be very odd , I think, if I didn't write anything about her. "I missed a lot at the beginning of the match". There are always going to be times when it's really tough, and there will be times when you're on an extreme high.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.