Privacy campaigner can sue Facebook, EU court hears

Share
Privacy campaigner can sue Facebook, EU court hears

Luxembourg, Nov 14 Austrian activist Max Schrems can not bring a class action against Facebook for privacy breaches, although he is allowed to sue the U.S. social media giant on a personal basis, the adviser to the EU's top court said today.

The advocate general to the European Court of Justice, Michal Bobek, said in a legal opinion that Schrems "may be able to rely on his consumer status in order to sue Facebook Ireland before the Austrian courts".

"Today's opinion supports the decisions of two courts that Mr Schrems's claims can not proceed as "class action" on behalf of other consumers in Austrian courts", a Facebook spokesman said in a statement to AFP.

Facebook initially disputed the jurisdiction of the Austrian courts in hearing such a claim, so the Austrian supreme court referred the matter to the ECJ in Luxembourg.

"The outcome would be that thousands of courts in the whole European Union would have to deal with an identical, but local lawsuit against Facebook", he said.

In addition to alleging that Facebook violated his own privacy and data-protection rights, he purports to represent seven Facebook users domiciled in Austria, German and India.

Class action suits, in which many people sue together, are not as common in Europe as they are in the U.S., but Schrems argued that individual Facebook users could not afford the legal costs of individually fighting their cases against the Silicon Valley tech giant.

Since 2010, he had used a Facebook account under his own name, spelled using the Cyrillic alphabet, for his private use.

Since 2011, he had used another Facebook page, containing information about lectures, participations in panel debates, media appearances, books he had written, a fundraiser he had launched and information about the legal proceedings he had initiated against Facebook Ireland.

The court heard he had assembled a team of ten individuals, with a core of five, to support him in "his campaign against Facebook".

Austria's Supreme Court asked for clarification on two questions: whether Schrems use of Facebook is professional must be considered professional because of his creation of a Facebook page, and whether the jurisdictional consumer privilege is strictly personal - not to be relied on for assigned claims.

Bobek said that publishing or lecturing in the field "do [es] not entail the loss of consumer status" for claims about a private, personal Facebook account.

Only in "exceptional scenarios" could an ulterior change in the account's use be taken into account.

The Advocate General held that Mr Schrem's knowledge, experience, civic engagement or the fact of having become famous for his legal action against Facebook did not in themselves prevent him from being a consumer.

"However, Mr Schrems can not rely on his consumer status with respect to claims assigned to him by other consumers".

Bobek said this would allow the concentration of claims in one jurisdiction - and to "choose the place of the more favourable courts" - that could lead to overburdening some jurisdictions.

Class actions in the European Union would mean litigants could effectively shop around the bloc for the "more favourable courts", lower costs or better legal aid, potentially overburdening some countries, the advocate general added.

The Data Protection Commissioner, Helen Dixon, took action at the High Court, urging the transfer of the case to the Court of Justice of the EU.

The full judgement on the case will be delivered in a number of months' time.

Although the court typically follows the officer's opinions, they are non-binding.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

India's Exports Fall in October
Rising crude oil prices led to the oil import bill rising 27.9 per cent in the month, from an 18.5 per cent rise in September. Imports, however, grew by 7.6 per cent to $37.11 billion in October from $34.5 billion in the corresponding month a year ago.

Manchester United must be ready for 'decisive' Christmas period: Juan Mata
Newcastle have only scored 10, however, so they're unlikely to cause Jose Mourinho's side too much trouble at Old Trafford in an attacking sense.

Sun Pharma Q2 net plunges 59% at Rs 912 cr
Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (API) business largely meant for captive consumption rose 6 percent to Rs 388 crores. However, the profit exceeded analysts' expectations of 8.27 billion rupees on back of a sharp cut in tax expenses.

Singapore workers to get 2.7% pay increase in 2018
By contrast employers expect to give pay rises which are roughly in line with inflation. On average, salaries in Asia are expected to increase by 5.9 per cent in 2018.

Japan's Koike Steps Down as Party Leader to Focus on Tokyo Post
The LDP on its own secured well beyond the 261 threshold defined as a "stable majority" in the 465-member lower house. She then led her party to a historic victory over the LDP in a July Tokyo assembly poll.

'Lord of the Rings' TV series in work at Amazon Studio
Amazon has committed to produce multiple seasons of a new television series based on the epic fantasy novel. The upcoming series will be available for Prime members globally.

Didier Drogba ready to retire in New Year
Drogba joined second-tier Phoenix in 2017, after leaving Montreal Impact following the conclusion of the 2016 MLS season. Once Chelsea's man for the big occasion, Didier Drogba has made a decision to call a day on his football career.

Apple overtakes Xiaomi to retain wearables lead in Q3 - Canalys
Apple is once again the biggest selling producer of wearables after its third-generation Apple Watch, launched in September. Canalys estimates that about 800,000 of the 3.9 million Apple Watch units sold in the third quarter were the LTE model.

Should Trump have control of USA nuclear weapons?
He said the USA system has evolved through tradition and precedent more than by laws. "This is a product of circumstances". Ted Lieu (D-Calif.) reintroduced their " Restricting First Use of Nuclear Weapons Act of 2017 " earlier this year.

Reese Witherspoon and Zendaya Team Up for a Girl Power-Fueled Film
Monica Beletsky is writing the script, and Hello Sunshine's Witherspoon and Lauren Neustadter are producing along with Zendaya . Homecoming star is no stranger to crafting stories behind the scenes, as she produced two episodes of Disney's K.C.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.