Privacy A Fundamental Right But A Qualified One: Centre To Supreme Court

Share
Privacy A Fundamental Right But A Qualified One: Centre To Supreme Court

"Every aspect of it does not qualify as a fundamental right, as privacy also includes the subtext of liberty", said the centre's lawyer KK Venugopal today.

Arguing for the Centre, AG Venugopal said that framers of the Constitution intentionally omitted mention of privacy as a fundamental right.

The bench is dealing with the limited issue of right to privacy and matters challenging the Aadhaar scheme would be referred back to a smaller bench.

"Privacy is a species of liberty, which is subordinate to the right to life".

There are several aspects to Right to Life such as right to food, shelter and employment but everything does not enjoy the status of a fundamental right, K K Venugopal said. According to an Indian Express report, an absolute right cannot be reduced or amended.

The Supreme Court of India will hear the government's arguments on Wednesday against the constitutional validity of right to privacy in the ongoing case that stemmed from petitioners opposing Aadhaar for privacy infringement. As a result, the question of whether the right to privacy is a fundamental right has resurfaced as the point of law around which the entire debate revolves.

Hearings related to the right to privacy and Aadhaar cards will resume on Thursday, where the respondents i.e. the State will resume its arguments. In the submission, he states that right to privacy is a "quintessential right flowing out of the bouquet of rights under enshrined under Article 21".

These submissions are in slight variance with the earlier stance of the Centre that the right is not a fundamental right and judgments subsequent to MP Sharma and Kharak Singh are per incuriam. He goes on to say that "present societal context where advances in technology and communication have transformed the relationship between stakeholders inter se and in particular the relationship between the State and its citizens". "This court needs to strike a balance", he submitted before the bench, PTI reported. "That is why we have the death penalty for gross crimes and incarceration for crimes". "Right to privacy can not be so absolute that it prevents the state from legislating or regulating it", the Constitution bench said.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Initial Coin Offerings May Be Subject to US Securities Laws, Says SEC
The federal securities laws provide disclosure requirements and other important protections of which investors should be aware. Whether the assets are purchased with dollars or virtual currency does not have any bearing.

Did Maldives govt lock down parliament to avoid vote?
He said the opposition MPs were pepper sprayed and tear gassed by the police, and stopped from entering the parliament. In 2015, he was sentenced to 13 years in prison on terrorism charges that were widely seen as politically motivated.

Chris Jericho Makes His Return on Tonight's WWE SmackDown (Video, Photos)
Now the "Ayatollah of Rock'n'Rolla" is back it'll be interesting to see who he's up against next in the build up to SummerSlam . Jericho was inserted into the match as he never got the rematch clause after losing the title to Owens a few months back.

Spalletti hopes for Perisic stay
That came as a blow to fans of the Red Devils, who had been lead to believe that Perisic was close to a switch to Old Trafford. Reports suggested that Inter had demanded £48m for the player, while Man United were reluctant to go above £40m.

Rail design led to deadliness of NY train crash — APNewsBreak
- The NTSB has concluded Metro-North Railroad is not to blame for the Valhalla, New York, train crash two and a half years ago. The extensive investigation focused on several factors, including signals at the crossing, the train engineer and Ms.

Taliban rout Afghan troops near Kandahar
Kabul has been battered by explosions claimed by the Taliban and by the Islamic State group's affiliate in Afghanistan. Several prominent political leaders, such as Hazara leader Mohammad Mohaqiq, live in western Kabul .

The Switch leads Nintendo into the green
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is even more impressive, achieving 3.54 million sales even though it was only released on April 28. It looks as if ARMS could end up soundly surpassing the sales of 1-2-Switch at its current pace.

Apple ordered to pay $506 million to university for processor patent infringement
The company was sued for making use of a "predictor circuit" developed by the Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation (WARF). While this case is seemingly wrapping up, Apple is still facing another lawsuit from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Amazon optimistic over Brexit amid United Kingdom expansion at new London HQ
Amazon has opened its new United Kingdom head office in London with the promise of doubling its research and development team in the country.

Transgender people won't be allowed to serve in US military
Last month, the Army had begun compulsory transgender sensitivity training for soldiers and civilian employees. President Donald Trump on Wednesday announced a ban on transgendered people from serving in the USA military.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.