Why court battle represents existential threat to Obamacare

Share
Why court battle represents existential threat to Obamacare

The judges focused on whether the 2010 Affordable Care Act lost its justification after Republican President Donald Trump in 2017 signed a law that eliminated a tax penalty used to enforce the ACA's mandate that all Americans buy health insurance.

A three-judge panel on the US 5th Circuit Court of Appeals will hear arguments on the case Tuesday afternoon and then rule in the coming weeks on whether the law should stand.

Two of the three judges on the appeals court panel - both appointed by Republican presidents - repeatedly pressed California's deputy solicitor general, who is defending the law, to explain why it should remain on the books after Congress in 2017 scrapped a penalty against people who didn't have health insurance. A lawsuit filed by 20 Republican State Attorney Generals claims that changes eliminating the individual mandate of the ACA have made it unconstitutional.

Any kind of ruling by a panel of three judges is likely to send the health care law to the Supreme Court, possibly in the midst of the 2020 presidential election.

In 2012, a divided U.S. Supreme Court upheld most of its provisions, including the individual mandate, which requires people to obtain insurance or pay a penalty.

But the state's Republican leaders have offered few ideas about what should replace Obamacare, a law that touches practically every aspect of health care regulations and includes several popular protections for patients. Gov.

A victory for plaintiffs assures that health care will once again be front and center on the campaign trail as Trump seeks reelection next year.

"If you no longer have the tax, why isn't it unconstitutional?"

Judge Kurt Engelhardt suggested Tuesday that court precedent strongly connected the requirement to get insurance, known as the "individual mandate", to protected coverage of preexisting conditions. That could become a key element of Tuesday's oral arguments.

U.S. Sen. Bob Casey joined Democrats at state and federal levels this week in calling on Republican lawmakers to take a stance on the lawsuit and its potential ramifications.

"President Trump has spent the last two years plus, sabotaging our health care system", Baldwin said, sharing stories of people impacted by the ACA.

"Seniors paying for drugs and Medicare and the young people on their parents' health insurance plans until the age of 26 will be affected". Another 800,000 Pennsylvanians enrolled in Medicaid expansion also could lose coverage.

Justice Department attorney August Flentje, facing questions about the administration's approach, said the government would enforce it until a final decision comes. Eighteen states, led by Texas, are challenging the federal health care law. "We, Democrats, will keep fighting, tooth and nail, to protect American's health care for as long as it takes and we will not stop until we succeed". Because the case is before one of the most conservative appellate courts in the country, it is nearly guaranteed to wind up in the Supreme Court. He said the legal remedy for those states would involve only the parts of the law that have harmed them. At stake: the subsidized health coverage of roughly 1 million Texans, sweeping protections for patients with preexisting conditions, young adults staying on their parents' insurance plans until age 26 and a host of low-priced benefits available to all people with health insurance, including those covered through their employers.

On Tuesday, Schumer and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi held up signs with the faces of Americans who they say would be hurt if Republicans succeed in their efforts to overturn the ACA.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order hero is male because of Rey
There are few Star Wars games where you can play as a woman, let alone as the protagonist. Fallen Order director has given a odd reason for why the game's protagonist is male.

OnePlus 7 Pro gets OxygenOS 9.5.9 update
The software update is basically for the company's flagship smartphone 7 Pro with the availability of the 5G feature. OnePlus 7 was launched in India along with OnePlus 7 Pro in May this year in Mirror Gray and Red color variants.

Pogba has been 'respectful and professional' in his attempts to leave United
They didn't listen to all the noise coming from around the Spanish club, and just got on with their preseason. Premier Mark McGowan said most of the tourists expected in the city are from Britain.

Disney star Cameron Boyce's cause of death requires 'further investigation'
Cameron was dancing lit up on stage and left everyone on their feet, cheering. "But we need to use our resources and what we have. The loss of Cameron Boyce is having a profound effect on anyone blessed enough to have known him.

At Least 9 Hurt in Pamplona Running of the Bulls
The race along the 850-metre cobbled-street course to the bullring lasted just over two minutes, the fastest so far this year. The bull's horn went deep into his neck and doctors told him it was "beyond miraculous" that it didn't hit a major artery.

Google reveals more Stadia details, including answers about multiplayer and VR
Google's gaming platform, however, will only be available for the said devices if they already have access to the Stadia app. However, purchasing or managing content can be done with any device running iOS 11 or Android M or higher on both platforms.

Djibouti Welcomes Agreement Between TMC and FFC
The council will include five civilians representing the protest movement and five military members. Tens of thousands of protesters flooded the streets of Sudan's cities in the run-up to the deal.

Weather system over eastern Florida has 50% chance of becoming cyclone - NHC
Atmospheric conditions are favorable for it to acquire a circulation and develop into a tropical depression or tropical storm. The only areas not included in the advisory is for parts of East Alabama where rain chances are more likely to occur.

Anaheim Police Department Confirms Viral Brawl At Disneyland Under Investigation
According to the Anaheim Police Department , everyone involved in the fight belongs to the same family. The man in the white shirt strikes one of the women (dressed in a striped tank top) in the face.

Top Dems invite champion US women's soccer team to Capitol
The U.S. team has captured the last two World Cups and has won four, more than any other country. It would be the US's women soccer team's fourth World Cup win since 1991.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.