Vaping much better smoking cessation aid than gum, patches, major study finds

Share
Vaping much better smoking cessation aid than gum, patches, major study finds

Vaping may be more effective to help smokers quit cigarettes over nicotine gums and patches, according to a new study. E-cigarettes, however, "provided greater satisfaction and were rated as more helpful to refrain from smoking than nicotine-replacement products", the study's authors wrote. People using NRT were more likely to report feeling sick (37.9% compared to 31.3% of e-cigarette users) while e-cigarette users were more likely to report throat or mouth irritation (65.3% compared to 51.2% of NRT users).

"Although a large number of smokers report that they have quit smoking successfully with the help of e-cigarettes, health professionals have been reluctant to recommend their use because of the lack of clear evidence from randomised controlled trials". Some full-time vapers spent longer than a year transitioning to e-cigarettes. The finding that e-cigarettes are nearly twice as effective as NRTs is similar to the results of a survey that health psychologist Robert West and his colleagues conducted several years ago. The results, reported yesterday in The New England Journal of Medicine, should encourage public health officials in the United States to embrace the harm-reducing potential of vaping, as their counterparts in the U.K. have been doing for years, rather than portraying e-cigarettes as a menace.

Findings from the nationally representative study, published online in JAMA Network Open, add to the growing evidence linking e-cigarette use to an increased risk for initiating cigarette smoking among youth, especially among low-risk teens.

"In our study, smokers used e-cigarettes much like other nicotine replacement treatments".

But for those kids considered to be at low risk for taking up smoking - who had initially said they had no interest in smoking, were risk averse and less likely to seek out new experiences - first using e-cigarettes raised the risk of eventual smoking by 8.57 times.

In a reverse analysis, the researchers behind the study also found an association between cigarette smoking and subsequent use of e-cigarettes, "suggesting that e-cigarettes may divert smokers toward e-cigarettes in some youths" while increasing the alternative risk of cigarette initiation among others who initially used e-cigarettes. "There is substantial evidence that they are less harmful than traditional cigarettes, but that doesn't mean they are not harmful".

People assigned to e-cigarettes reported less severe urges to smoke in the first 4 weeks of the study.

Several factors may have boosted the results: All the participants were recruited from a government smoking-cessation program and were presumably motivated to quit.

Myth #1: E-cigarettes give you popcorn lung.

By the 52nd week, 18 per cent of the e-cigarette group was still off cigarettes, compared to 9.9 per cent of the standard treatment group.

While nicotine plays a part, Stokes thinks the influence of vaping is "more complex than just nicotine". The study looked at diacetyl levels in e-cigarettes, but never implied that e-cigarettes cause this disease.

The study was welcomed by Public Health England, whose tobacco control lead said that stop smoking services should welcome people who want to stop smoking with the help of e-cigarettes.

But Jordt noted that newer devices like the Juul pod have only recently arrived in the UK. "E-cigs have numerous same toxicants of traditional cigs but at lower levels".

Earlier this month the head of the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), Scott Gottlieb, said he was so concerned about teenage use of the devices that he is considering the radical step of banning them completely. People who said they had stopped smoking after 1 year were asked to attend for a carbon monoxide screen to confirm their claim.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

January 30 is Bell Let's Talk Day
Becky Carveth has lived with multiple mental illnesses for years, and today, she helps others deal with mental illness. The grants are given out on one-year terms and the deadline to apply for the next round of funding is March 15, 2019.

Weir quizzed by cops over racehorse shocks
Racing Victoria chief executive Giles Thompson says it is too early to say if Weir, 48, would be suspended from the sport. A veteran of Australia's racing industry, Mr Weir holds the national record for the most wins by a trainer in a season.

Former Bear Julius Peppers retires after 17-year career
In another video he posted along with a full-length article on The Player's Tribune he says, "It's a little weird to say it... Peppers finishes his career fourth on the NFL's All-Time sack list, behind Bruce Smith, Reggie White and Kevin Greene .

Skip the toast? Why breakfast might not be that important after all
If your aim is to shed a few kilos, it turns out breakfast isn't the most important meal of the day after all. The scientists aren't the first to challenge the supposed link between eating breakfast and weight loss .

Chicago Bulls to waive Carmelo Anthony, could land with Lakers
Carmelo Anthony has been waived by the Chicago Bulls , making the 10-time All-Star forward a free agent. That finally happened on Friday afternoon, and one of Anthony's former squads played a major role.

First trailer for The Rock’s "Hobbs & Shaw" film released
With the new trailer now starting the gas again in the Fast & Furious , fans are seeking, as they've termed it, #JusticeForHan. Folks, hold your breath as the first trailer for the spinoff movie Hobbs & Shaw has released today and we can't keep calm.

Virginia Governor Northam Wore Racist Costume in Yearbook
Ralph Northam's page in his 1984 Eastern Virginia Medical School yearbook. So I think this was really blown out of proportion".

First Facebook, now Google’s internal iOS apps are blocked by Apple
Most users got $20 monthly gift cards from Facebook in exchange for using the app, and some were also given paid referral fees. In an internal memo sent on Wednesday, Facebook told employees it is "working closely" with Apple to reinstate access.

Elizabeth Warren apologizes to Cherokee Nation for DNA test
She even contributed a number of allegedly Native American recipes to a "Pow Wow Chow " cookbook edited by her cousin. At first, Trump denied making any promise to donate $1 million to charity if Warren completed the test.

6 quake hits Mexico; no reports of death or serious injury
A 7.1-magnitude quake struck central Mexico in September 2017, causing widespread damage and killing at least 370 people. There have been no reports of immediate damage, but the epicenter of the quake hit at a depth of 42 miles.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.