Don't think collegium should be entrusted with allocation of cases

Share
Don't think collegium should be entrusted with allocation of cases

A day after Justice J Chelameswar refused to examine a PIL by former Union law minister Shanti Bhushan saying he did not want his order to be reversed again in 24 hours, another bench of the court on Friday made a decision to examine the PIL which had challenged the existing roster practice of allocation of cases by the Chief Justice of India (CJI).

"Prima facie, I dont think the Collegium should be treated as the Chief Justice of India", Justice Sikri said.

"Lakhs of cases are filed here". Justice Sikri asked Dave at one point.

"That is not my case".

"In 14 cases, the CJI used his power and this raises very, very serious questions". That has not been happening in many cases.

During the arguments, Dave said that "sensitive" cases should be allocated by the collegium as in a democracy, there was "nothing called absolute discretion" and there were matters which were "sensitive" for the nation and for survival of democracy.

Justice Bhushan told Dave that "what may be "sensitive" for you may not be sensitive for us (the Supreme Court)".

Without referring to the merits of Justice Chelameswars order, Dave said that since the CJI was hearing a Constitution bench case at that time, Justice Chelameswars order in that matter was "valid".

However, responding to these submissions, Justice Sikri observed that interpreting the CJI to include the collegium of senior judges was "not feasible".

"You are aggreived by the manner of exercise of power by CJI".

"It can not be expected that the collegium will sit everyday or two-three days a week for this only".

Dave then cited the instance of an arbitrary listing by a former CJI and how the Supreme Court later undid the damage in review. "If you can come up with some other suggestion, then maybe we could consider", said Sikri J. After he retired, all those orders were reviewed.

However, Dave said, "But there is caveat. You have to devise a procedure not for us, but for the sake of the institution", Kapil Sibal weighed in.

A Bench of Justices A.K. Sikri and Ashok Bhushan asked Attorney-General K.K. Venugopal to assist the court and posted the next hearing for April 27.

The apex court bench will examine the petition despite two of its judgments supporting - dated November 2017 and April 9, 2018 upholding the CJI as the complete administrative authority to allocate cases and constitute Benches. Both judgments were pronounced by Benches led by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra.

On November 10 previous year, a five-judge constitution bench had overturned the order passed by the bench headed by Justice Chelameswar, which had asked for setting up a larger bench to hear the matter of alleged bribes being taken in the name of judges.

The petition also enlists a number of politically sensitive cases in which there was "gross abuse of power" as regards listing.

On the submission of the petitioner that important cases should be heard by CJI and other four senior most judges of the Supreme Court, the bench indicated that while it would be hard to entrust task of allocation of important cases to Collegium headed by CJI, it was not averse to devising some alternative yet feasible mechanism for allocation of cases to benches.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Syrian air defences shot down 13 missiles
The UK Air Force's Tornado aircraft fired eight Scalp EG missiles. According to some sources, ten or so targets were attacked.

Commonwealth Games 2018: Record-breaking Sanjeev Rajput shoots gold
He started extremely slow and despite a strong Prone round, Chain Singh failed to catch up with his opponents and finished 5th. He held on to the second position with a score of 306.9 by the end of the Prone round.

Zuckerberg gets richer after his testimony to Congress in data scandal
With a four-minute time limit, the members of congress have significantly less time to press Zuckerberg , to the CEO's advantage. Mr Zuckerberg welcomed the idea of regulation and cautiously endorsed a forthcoming European law on data protection.

Commonwealth Games 2018: Galadima claims 8th gold for Nigeria
Chaudhry further said: "There are six athletes in the apartment". "Why did they take action on both athletes?" As per the CWG policy, athletes must have a specific medical exemption to possess needles at the Games.

Roach hurt by Pacquiao decision
Roach has been Pacquiao's lead coach since 2002 after gaining the International Boxing Federation super bantamweight champion. Via Yahoo Sports' Kevin Iole, Roach confirmed the split and bares that he was hurt by how it all went down.

Leaked Apple memo: 12 employees were arrested a year ago for leaking secrets
The memo went on to explain how to avoid being finessed into giving away information to the press who "pry for information". Leaks have become more common under CEO Tim Cook , but this memo claims numerous supply chain leaks have been stopped.

State Street Corp Has Boosted Its Pfizer INC (PFE) Position
State Street Corp increased its stake in Pfizer Inc ( PFE ) by 0.26% based on its latest 2017Q4 regulatory filing with the SEC. Leerink Swann maintained Pfizer Inc. (NYSE:PFE) earned "Overweight" rating by Morgan Stanley on Wednesday, September 20.

On May, 7 Rayonier Advanced Materials Inc. (RYAM) EPS Estimated At $0.43
After $0.50 EPS was published last quarter, analysts now see negative EPS growth of -14.00 % for Rayonier Advanced Materials Inc. RBC Capital Markets upgraded Rayonier Advanced Materials Inc. (NYSE:RYAM) on Tuesday, September 13 to "Sector Perform" rating.

RI State Troopers to run in Boston Marathon
Ronald Longolucco, who will be running his fifth Boston Marathon and Trooper Amy Jackman, who will be running her third. Even the 26-year-old made it finishing third at Boston and Chicago.

Media houses get HC notice for identifying Kathua rape victim
The High Court, in its notices to media houses, have sought their response as to why no action should be taken against them. The high court expressed concern over the authorities not taking any action against the violators of law.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.