Supreme Court agrees to review law banning political apparel at polling places

Share
Supreme Court agrees to review law banning political apparel at polling places

The U.S. Supreme Court will consider guaranteeing the right of people to wear political T-shirts and buttons when they vote, accepting an appeal that could expand First Amendment rights at polling places. Members of those organizations, concerned about ineligible voters casting ballots, turned up on Election Day wearing buttons reading "Please ID me", and at least one person wore a T-shirt with a Tea Party logo that said "Don't tread on me".

Cilek sued, arguing that the law should be overturned because it violated his free speech rights and was too broad, requiring enforcement based on the subjective judgment by election officials about what types of messages have political overtones.

Though the U.S. Supreme Court has permitted campaign-free zones at polling places, it has never endorsed a ban on all political speech, the Minnesota Voters Alliance asserts in its cert petition (PDF).

State officials, including Attorney General Nathan Hartshorn, urged the Supreme Court not to hear the case, saying lower courts have uniformly upheld similar rules elsewhere. "It essentially creates a speech-free zone in the polling place". "Such a limitless ban on personal expression is unconstitutional".

Since 1987, Texas has barred the wearing of a "badge, insignia, emblem or other similar communicative device" that relates to a candidate, ballot measure, political party or the way an election is run. That law didn't mention more general political items.

The court will take up a case originally filed in 2010 by three conservative or libertarian groups: the Minnesota North Star Tea Party Patriots, the Minnesota Majority and the Minnesota Voters Alliance.

"It just keeps things happier that way", she said.

County and state officials say the court got it right because "the interior of a polling place is a nonpublic forum in which speech restrictions are constitutional as long as they are reasonable and viewpoint neutral".

The high court announced Monday, Nov. 13, that it accepted the Minnesota Voters Alliance appeal from the 8th U.S.Circuit Court of Appeals, which had upheld the law.

"'Speech-free zones' can not be reconciled with the First Amendment's free speech clause", the challengers argued in court papers.

Share

Advertisement

Related Posts

Ole Miss WR AJ Brown named semifinalist for Biletnikoff Award
The Biletnikoff Award released a list of 10 semifinalists for the national award with Brown still in the running. Washington's 35 career touchdown receptions and 4,081 receiving yards lead active FBS players.

Public raise $50000 for cyclist who flipped off President Trump
Briskman lost her government contractor job last week after a photo of her giving Trump's motorcade the finger in northern Virginia , on October 28, made worldwide news .

Guys, there might be more Gilmore Girls episodes on the way
While there is nothing in the works just yet, Sherman-Palladino isn't taking the world of Gilmore Girls off the table forever. "But it's definitely possible".

Jeff Lynne's ELO announces 2018 United Kingdom and Ireland tour
The tour was announced just a few days before the release of the band's live concert CD and DVD Wembley or Bust on Friday. One (1) code is granted per customer and allows access to purchase up to four (4) tickets.

Dallas Assistant District Attorney Loses Job For Berating Uber Driver
He said she was intoxicated and she got angry when she told him to deviate from directions on his Global Positioning System . Warner: "We'll wait for the cops". "You don't just end a ride ..." Just take me home, dude.

Gas prices in MA up 6 cents this week
DeHaan has observed that the cheapest price this year was in July and the most expensive price was when Hurricane Harvey hit. DeHaan said Florida is still in the early stages of this, but he has increasingly noticed it in recent months.

American International Group Inc Decreases Its Holdings in Costco Wholesale (COST) Stock
Currently, 437.8 million total shares are owned by the public and among those 434.07 million shares have been available to trade. The stock witnessed 8.99% gains, 8.52% gains and -0.12% declines for the 1-month, 3-month and 6-month period, respectively.

Steelers CB Joe Haden says he'll be back soon
Although the Steelers have yet to rule Haden out for the rest of the season, he will likely miss several weeks due to the injury. Haden signed with the Pittsburgh Steelers on August 30th, just hours after being released by the Cleveland Browns .

Pennymac Mortgage Investment Trust (PMT) Shares Hovering Above Chikou
The stock of PennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust (NYSE:PMT) has "Neutral" rating given on Monday, February 6 by Compass Point. It fall, as 43 investors sold RES shares while 59 reduced holdings. 35 funds opened positions while 66 raised stakes.

'Transracial' man was born white, identifies as Filipino
Whereas he hasn't yet told his family about his Filipino identity, he has told them that he is considering changing his gender. Ja Du said he's part of a growing " transracial " community in which people are born one race, but identify with another.

© 2015 ExpressNewsline. All Rights reserved.